BMJ 2007;334:1285-1286 (23 June), doi:10.1136/bmj.39252.411192.80
Editorials
Centralised application services for specialist training
Other countries manage
This week marks the end of round one of the UK's scheme to fill specialty training posts that become available in August. All applicants have been offered the opportunity of at least one job interview, and those who have not been offered a job can apply for any unfilled posts in round two. For this second round, however, local deaneries will manage the process. The Medical Training Application Service (MTAS), whose premature and poorly implemented introduction was condemned by a judge for its "disastrous consequences,"1 has been shelved.
Good riddance, chorus Britain's doctors, but the decision brings little comfort to the thousands of demoralised juniors still caught up in the uncertainties and frustrations of finding a job. While assessing the ongoing fallout of MTAS, it's salutary to be reminded that other countries have pulled off what looks from Britain like an impossible feat. In this week's journal, Tony Jefferis reports that "a central application portal with local selection . . . has been used successfully in the United States, Canada, and, in a modified form in Australia and New Zealand for at least 30 years." And these countries have successfully negotiated, or are negotiating, the transition to computerisation.2
What can Britain learn from their example? Jefferis found that other countries' matching schemes "are all efficient, have clear time tables, and are consistent from year to year." Candidates have time "to make informed choices and to compile their application."
Britain's year one was always going to be tough, but many things made it tougher, in ways that those responsible for its implementation should have predicted. Computer crashes and security breaches are par for the course for the United Kingdom's public sector information technology projects, few of which deliver on time, on budget, and to specification.3 By opting for a "big bang" approach—including all training jobs, at all levels, in all geographical areas—the system was maximally stressed. An added complication was that while the senior house officer (SHO) grade is disappearing overnight, the many doctors filling such posts aren't, and nor are the service needs they have been fulfilling.
The breakneck speed with which the changes were introduced just about overwhelmed the human resources needed to process the applications. The need to build in flexibility was sacrificed to getting the scheme off the ground. Many juniors, and those who should have been advising them, did not appreciate the scale of cultural change and how qualitatively different the new selection process was going to be. Understanding—let alone "buy in"—was lacking.
The next substantial criticism of the new system was that it was a poor discriminator of applicants. (The "evidence" for this is the large numbers of "high flyers" without job offers, a claim that will have to await the end of round two for proper substantiation.) The new application form was blamed for giving precedence to free text answers about competency over evidence of clinical experience.4 Its masking of medical school and country of training—an attempt to reduce discrimination—was seized on as a weakness rather than a strength.
The countries that Jefferis analysed do things the way Britain used to. All have application forms covering undergraduate and graduate training, honours and prizes, research and publications, and extracurricular and community activity. To help in selection, all four countries use reports and references—from medical school deans, referees, supervisors, and the like (some solicited by telephone). Programme directors rank candidates in order of preference using the application form, references, and interview. Candidates' preferences and those of the programmes are then matched centrally, "without controversy." Jefferis doesn't explore how these systems protect candidates from selectors' biases towards "people like us,"5 which was a laudable aim of the UK's proposals.
The remaining serious criticism of MTAS was that it would leave 12 000 junior doctors jobless from August, which no amount of tweaking with computer programs or application forms would have altered. A large proportion of the "excess" applicants are thought to be doctors trained overseas—including some working in non-training grade trust posts, some doing unpaid observerships or locums as they try to get substantive appointments, and others currently overseas. Jefferis found that the countries he looked at avoided these problems—while international graduates made up an integral part of their medical workforce their applications were considered only after those of domestic graduates.
John Tookes's inquiry into the UK's specialty training scheme, Modernising Medical Careers, is looking much more widely than merely "the mechanics of the process," although it is hard to imagine this won't consume a lot of its attention, given the shortfalls of the discredited system. In its current consultation phase the inquiry wants to explore "alternative solutions, grounded in evidence." Jefferis's article shows that a scheme that combines central computerised application with local selection is not necessarily an impossible dream.
|
Tony Delamothe, deputy editor
BMJ, London WC1H 9JR
tdelamothe{at}bmj.com
Competing interests: My wife, who is an obstetrician and gynaecologist, has short listed and interviewed ST1 candidates for the London Deanery.
Provenance and peer review: Commissioned; not externally peer reviewed.
References
- Eaton L. Remedy UK loses its high court case. http://blogs.bmj.com/category/comment/mtas/.
- Jefferis T. Selection for specialist training: what can we learn from other countries? BMJ 2007 doi: 10.1136/bmj.39238.447338.AD
[Free Full Text] - O'Dowd A. Richard Granger resigns as chief executive of Connecting for Health. BMJ 2007 doi: 10.1136/bmj.39251.605475.DB
[Free Full Text] - Coombes R. MTAS: which way now? BMJ 2007 doi: 10.1136/bmj.39252.407350.68
[Free Full Text] - Esmail A, Everington S. Racial discrimination against doctors from ethnic minorities. BMJ 1993:306:691-2.
CiteULike 
Complore 
Connotea 
Del.icio.us 
Digg 
Reddit 
Technorati What's this?
Relevant Articles
- Medical immigration: the elephant in the room
- Graham Winyard
BMJ 2007 335: 593-595.[Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]
- Richard Granger resigns as chief executive of Connecting for Health
- Adrian O'Dowd and Michael Cross
BMJ 2007 334: 1290-1291.[Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]
-
MTAS: which way now?
BMJ 2007 334: 1300.[Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]
- Selection for specialist training: what can we learn from other countries?
- Tony Jefferis
BMJ 2007 334: 1302-1304.[Extract] [Full Text] [PDF]
This article has been cited by other articles:
-
Pashayan, N., Duff, C., Mason, B. W.
(2007). Selection into specialty training in public health: performance of the Medical Training Application Service shortlisting. J Public Health (Oxf)
29: 331-337
[Abstract] [Full text] -
Winyard, G.
(2007). Medical immigration: the elephant in the room. BMJ
335: 593-595
[Full text]
Rapid Responses:
Read all Rapid Responses
- An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Morris J Brown, et al.
bmj.com, 22 Jun 2007 [Full text] - A smooth run-through?
- Sean P J Lynch
bmj.com, 22 Jun 2007 [Full text] - protecting professionalism
- J. Martin Dace
bmj.com, 22 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Research and the MTAS disaster
- Joe Herbert
bmj.com, 23 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Of course
- David Curtis
bmj.com, 23 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Jonathan Roos
bmj.com, 23 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Silent demise of autonomy
- Klaus K Witte
bmj.com, 23 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Juniors' Jobs
- Gordon W Stewart
bmj.com, 23 Jun 2007 [Full text] - This is no way to treat entrants to a caring profession
- Clive W Richards
bmj.com, 23 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MTAS: Make a change
- Tony Heagerty, et al.
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Disgust and shame
- Matthew J Knight
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Paul N Rogers
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - shocked
- Gursharan l kashyap
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- emma gudgin
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Prof Brown is absolutely correct
- Nick P Martin
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - When in a hole stop digging
- Jane Deal
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Betrayal of a generation - the repurcussions
- Waqas Ullah
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - A debt of gratitude
- Steven D Vidgeon
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Colleges cannot stick their heads in the sand
- Alasdair Miller
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Is it too late?
- Mark D. Bloomfield
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - The career lottery.
- maitrayee choudhury
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Scarp MMC
- M Farouk
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - The failure of representation
- Vincent Connolly
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - An aplication service to flood the medical labour market
- Clive Peedell
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Did i apply for the wrong level
- Manotheethan Jegasothy, et al.
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Abandon MTAS
- john roberts
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Time for new leadership
- Mark R McCartney, et al.
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MTAS
- Thomas Britton
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Defining Moment
- Nick J Sarkies
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Nadine S Granger
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Support for statement
- John M Morgan
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Gordon Caldwell
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - protecting professionalism
- Bates David
bmj.com, 24 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Centralised Application Process
- Andrew W McCombe
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - The Royal Colleges must stand up
- Daniel P Gale
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Bruce J Finlayson
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Please return powers to the Colleges and disband PMETB
- j wace
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Adam S Onyett
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Royal Colleges must finally speak up for their members and their profession
- Amanda J Taffinder
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Dominic P Rogers
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Doctors as the Miners of the Middle Class
- Christopher M Rayner
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - A request for support from the Royal College of Physicians
- Abhijoy Chakladar
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Thanks Prof Brown
- Max Priesemann
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Illogical
- Neil D Citron
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MMC Debacle
- Paul D McGeoch
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Support for Fidelio
- Robert A Price
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - What now?
- Yvonne M Cartwright
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Medical Royal Colleges need to reclaim authority for postgraduate education and training
- David B Hocken MS FRCS
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Time for action.
- J. David Leopold
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - All too familiar
- Rachel M Nicholson
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Stephen R Ford
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - blame the game, not the player
- Jalil Ahmed
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Chris Chung
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Full support to Prof Brown
- Tom D Cosker
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - In support of Morris Brown.
- Alan J Carson
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Paul J Andrews
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - In support of Prof. Brown
- Ally Rooney
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Doctors should take back control
- Clio Bellenis
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - We must act now.
- Felicity J Meyer
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An Open Appeal
- Louella Vaughan
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: Support for statement
- Ian F Russell
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - The current state of play
- Christopher Twine
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Michael Douek
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - total complacency amongst the royal colleges
- Katrina L John
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MTAS- the other debacle
- Graham P WINYARD
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Stay united and lobby for more consultant posts
- Damian J Kelly
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Time for the College Presidents to Act
- Richard J Motley
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Another victim's perspective
- Ben S Clark
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Department of Health and the Royal Colleges - Special Relationship?
- Boyd Ghosh
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Insult after insult
- shelley dale Riphagen
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Keep the new name, just bring back the old system
- Adrian J McKenna
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Royal Colleges must stop being so spineless
- Jan K Melichar
bmj.com, 25 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Please help us
- Onkar S Dhillon
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Christopher H Blake
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: An open appeal to our Royal College presidents: Please stand together for our Juniors
- Helena Tabry
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Support for Prof Brown and colleagues
- Paul A Clarke
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - More support for Prof Brown
- Ben Underwood
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - I am a moron
- Rahul V Bhintade
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MMC/MTAS, The BMA and the Royal Colleges
- Peter McNamee
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MMC
- Allan P Corder, et al.
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Well done Morris Brown et al
- Charles P Warlow
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Experience of a national recruitment process for general practice
- Mayur Lakhani, et al.
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Disgusting and Demoralising
- Chris D Briggs
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MTAS Disaster
- Lynne Carmen Fryer
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - The dilemma of through-run MMC training
- Michael J. Kelly
bmj.com, 26 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Damage limitation
- s judd
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Accountability and Integrity
- Alastair R Deery
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Is anyone out there in favour of the current MTAs/MMC system?
- mary g harrington
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MTAS: A Disaster
- Charles N McCollum
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - What now for the dispossessed?
- Glenis K Scadding
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - MTAS shambles
- Allistair Stark
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Let's stop being so nicey nice
- Louise M Pealing
bmj.com, 27 Jun 2007 [Full text] - fomenting poor morale within the profession and hampering change
- Dan Harding
bmj.com, 28 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Morris Brown speaks for the profession
- Ruth M MacInerney
bmj.com, 28 Jun 2007 [Full text] - In support of Prof Brown
- D Owen
bmj.com, 28 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Plan B
- Simon T Adams
bmj.com, 29 Jun 2007 [Full text] - We have let our Juniors Down
- Daniel M Sado
bmj.com, 29 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: Let's stop being so nicey nice
- Tom A Milligan
bmj.com, 29 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Re: Support for Prof Brown and colleagues
- Catriona Sykes, et al.
bmj.com, 30 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Further support for Prof Brown.
- Jamie Peyton
bmj.com, 30 Jun 2007 [Full text] - Medical reforms put patients at risk
- Jane E Graham
bmj.com, 30 Jun 2007 [Full text] - A robust stance is required
- Duncan J M Macdonald
bmj.com, 30 Jun 2007 [Full text] - cogs in a machine
- Iona Heath
bmj.com, 3 Jul 2007 [Full text] - Rage Against the Machine
- Jasjit K Dhillon
bmj.com, 3 Jul 2007 [Full text] - Numerical indicator nonsense
- JOHN HUTCHINSON
bmj.com, 4 Jul 2007 [Full text] - loss of confidence
- Philip J Dawson
bmj.com, 22 Jul 2007 [Full text]
This Article
-
Extract
- Respond to this article
- Read responses to this article
- Alert me when this article is cited
- Alert me when responses are posted
- Alert me when a correction is posted
- View citation map
Services
- Email this article to a friend
- Find similar articles in BMJ
- Find similar articles in ISI Web of Science
- Find similar articles in PubMed
- Add article to my folders
- Download to citation manager
- Request Permissions
Citing Articles
- Read articles citing this article
- Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (2)
- Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
PubMed
Related Content
Bookmark with
What's new
Latest blogs
Services
Tools
Online poll
Resources
Rapid responses for this article
Most read
Print issues
